When it comes to surfing vs SUP, also known as Stand-Up Paddling, finding the right activity for you may seem challenging. However, once you start to understand the nuances of each sport, the answer will seem much clearer for most readers.
In a nutshell, if you are a speed freak and you prefer to use your mobility and agility to get through obstacles, then surfing is for you. When you’re rewarded with the optimum weather conditions, then nothing can get your adrenaline pumping than riding the waves.
On the other hand, if you prefer having the opportunity to appreciate the serene and calm surroundings while also experiencing the roughest of water terrains, then SUP should look appealing to you. Either way, the goal of this article is to determine which one suits you best.
Would you rather glide through the water or conquer the nastiest waves with grace?
Equipment and Gear
The beauty of surfing is that most of the time, you only need your surfboard, and you’re ready to shred. However, beginners are highly encouraged to wear a leash at all times. They are also recommended to wear wetsuits or rash guards for safety.
When it comes to SUP essentials, the most common gear you would need is your Stand-Up paddleboard and paddle. You would also need to haul your trusty air pump so you can adjust the stiffness of your board before venturing out.
How much does it cost?
If you are planning to surf on a budget, the minimum investment needed is between $1,000 and $1,500 bucks, especially if you’re willing to buy used gear. For SUP, the cheapest set would cost you $450-$800 bucks (inflatable). For non-inflatable ones, prepare to spend upwards of $1,700.
Skills and Techniques
Since surfing has been around for centuries, it’s easy to understand why there are already a ton of skills and techniques you can learn, even at a beginner level. As your board handling improves, expect to learn different tricks along the way.
While SUP is a versatile water activity, not everything is based on creating impossible tricks. In fact, some people have incorporated yoga while on SUP and so much more. If you can do it while balancing, then you can probably do it on a stand-up paddleboard.
Surfing: The basics of surfing can be quite challenging for beginners, especially if they have limited knowledge or experience balancing on a board. It’s not something that you can learn overnight, so expect to book multiple coaching sessions to improve your skills.
SUP: The basics of Stand-Up Paddling are so straightforward that you can learn everything in a day. The learning curve becomes ridiculous once you tackle the different water and wind conditions of your chosen spot or if you try SUP surfing.
Surfing is meant to be experienced on playful shorelines where waves are constantly moving towards the shore. Riding on a surfboard feels rigid yet agile because of how it responds to the water. Your feet will feel every vibration that the waves throw at you.
Compared to surfing, SUP is more forgiving to beginners as it’s easier to control and maneuver. Since the paddleboard is meant to glide on water, calm waters feel buttery smooth, and wavy waters offer challenges that can test your balance and composure.
The dangers of surfing have been around since its invention, but that didn’t stop people from enjoying the activity. As long as you follow the surfing etiquette, then the chances for accidents will diminish greatly.
While SUP is considered to be less risky than surfing, it doesn’t mean that there aren’t safety protocols in place. Wearing a personal flotation device (PFD) along with your leash can greatly minimize the risk of drowning.
Culture and Community
While the surf culture is as diverse as ever, it doesn’t make it very challenging to socially interact with fellow surfers. It’s safe to assume that almost every country has its own thriving hotspot of like-minded people looking to share experiences from all walks of life.
The tricky part about the SUP culture is that there are other subcultures available for the sport which makes it challenging to find the right folks. Regardless, you can expect a friendly and welcoming atmosphere once you interact with the community.
Health and Fitness Perks
Both SUP and surfing offer a myriad of health and mental benefits for every adventurer. Both activities require you to stay on your toes, giving you a full-body workout with every movement (especially when paddling).
If you want a toned upper-body workout without hitting the gym, then SUP and surfing are for you. While SUP is low-impact and surfing can be both low and high-impact activities, it’s safe to say that your fitness levels would greatly improve over time.
Pros and Cons of Surfing
The Good: Very affordable to get started. One of the best ways to get that natural high. Unrivaled culture and community around the world. A deeper appreciation of the ocean and nature.
The Bad: Surfing is not for the faint of heart. Expect a steeper learning curve compared to SUP. Risks can vary from scratches to life-threatening situations. Your sessions don’t always guarantee quality waves.
Pros and Cons of Stand-Up Paddle
The Good: You can paddle your way to virtually anywhere that has enough body of water. It’s very easy to learn for beginners. Its versatility is unmatchable for calm and rough waters. It also provides a full-body workout.
The Bad: Strong winds and currents can easily affect the stability of the board. Maneuverability is not its strongest suit. The very noticeable flex in the middle of the board can cause balance issues for some. It may not provide the same dopamine hit as surfing.
Which sport is for you? While both surfing and SUP are delightful activities and are different from each other, it doesn’t mean you can’t do both. There’s a reason SUP surfing is one of the fastest-growing watersports activity.
Sure, your surfboard has some limitations on its use case, but it provides the best experience possible when tackling waves. Stand-up paddles, on the other hand, have unrivaled versatility which makes it a great companion for various bodies of water.
Regardless of your choice, the best guarantee here is that you will learn a new skill, discover new communities, and be one with nature on a regular basis.